ASK STACY: Skeletons in the Closet, Assets Hidden Under the Mattress

Every October, many of my neighbors decorate their front yards for the holiday. And that means lots of plastic skeletons adorning porches. Literally, the skeletons have come out of the closet. That expression actually originates in Victorian England, where the novelist William Makepeace Thackeray wrote that there is a skeleton in every house. Mind you, he was not writing about crime. He meant that even respectable families keep things hidden away and would rather not display them.

After four decades of practicing family law, I can attest that the closets are real and that divorce is what opens them. So, cue the spooky music while I do my best to answer more of your pressing questions:

ASK STACY: My boyfriend and I lived together for six years before we finally got married last year. During that time, we bought a car together, split rent, and I helped pay off some of his student loans. If we ever divorce, would California courts consider anything we built during those unmarried years, or does the clock only start ticking on our wedding day?

MY THOUGHTS: Courts can look at what happened before the wedding in two ways. The first is a Marvin claim, named for the litigation involving the actor Lee Marvin. If you can prove that the two of you had an agreement, written or spoken, that you would share what you built and take care of each other for life, a court can enforce it. That is a difficult case to make, and most couples never make any such agreement in the first place. Without one, the answer is no.

The second is the title. If you bought the car together and both your names are on the title, you own it together, and marrying later doesn't change that. You mentioned rent, so I gather you never owned the home, which means there is nothing to divide. Something he bought stays his, and something you bought stays yours.

Now for the part that stings. When you put your money toward paying down a loan that belongs to him, unless you have a contract with him you can prove, whether written or oral, the law will likely treat what you gave as a gift. For all practical purposes, the clock starts at the marriage. And even in a marriage, paying down his loan will likely be considered a gift.

ASK STACY: I have spent the last eleven years as a corporate litigator, and I am miserable. Family law has always interested me, but I worry I have built a narrow skill set that will not transfer. Is switching into family law this late realistic, and if so, what would you tell someone starting over in a completely different courtroom?

MY THOUGHTS: It is absolutely realistic. I have hired lawyers who spent considerably more than eleven years in litigation before moving into family law, and they have done well here. Consider your skill set. If you are a litigator, you understand the architecture of a case. You know discovery, depositions, interrogatories, requests for admission, subpoenas, etc. You know how to file a motion, how to argue in court, and how to take a deposition. That foundation is the hard part to build, and you have already built it. The substance you can learn.

Unless you sat inside a narrow specialty, every case brought a different industry and a different body of law, and you learned each one as it came. Family law is no different. It is learnable, provided you have the foundation of being a lawyer. My practical advice is to make the move and join a team; don't try to go it alone. The learning curve is much kinder when people around you have already climbed it.

ASK STACY: I recently found out my husband's affair started with a coworker who I believe pursued him aggressively even after learning he was married. A friend mentioned something called 'alienation of affection' that lets you sue the person who broke up your marriage. Is that actually a real legal claim I could bring here in California? If not, are there any other legal options available for me to address infidelity or betrayal?

MY THOUGHTS: Your friend is describing something real, and it does exist in a small number of states. California is not one of them. Our Legislature abolished alienation of affection here in 1939, along with the related claims for criminal conversation and breach of promise of marriage, under Civil Code Section 43.5.

California is also a no-fault state, which means a court will not weigh who did what to whom in a sexual way when it dissolves the marriage or divides the estate. In the eyes of the Family Code, the conduct that hurt you most is not part of the court’s purview. I know that's not easy to hear.

One thing worth noting, though, is that if your husband spent community money on this relationship, that is a different conversation, because a spouse who deliberately dissipates marital assets can be made to account for it. Gather the records and bring that question to your attorney.

ASK STACY: My husband moved to Texas for work eight months ago while I stayed in California with our kids. We have decided to divorce, but now we are arguing about where to file the case. Does it matter who files first, or does one state automatically have more claims than the other?

MY THOUGHTS: To file anywhere, one of you has to be a resident of that state. If you have never lived in Texas, Texas has no jurisdiction over you. California does have jurisdiction over your husband, and your children are here, so custody belongs in California and so does child support. Assuming you have no ties to Texas of your own, the divorce belongs here as well.

Just don't get too complacent with that answer. Talk to a lawyer and go over your facts. Filing by itself settles very little. Filing and serving settle it. So get moving. File, serve, and proceed.

ASK STACY: My divorce was finalized two years ago, and I recently stumbled across a bank statement proving my ex-husband was hiding a substantial account the entire time we were negotiating our settlement. Is it too late to do anything, or can a final divorce judgment be reopened once fraud like this comes to light?

MY THOUGHTS: If an asset was omitted from the Judgment, whether by oversight or design, the court still has jurisdiction over that asset, and the two-year period doesn't close the door the way it does for other issues.

Your question also raises a broader issue: whether the court can set aside the entire Judgment. Those are different rules with real deadlines attached, so raise both paths with your attorney and be clear about which relief you actually want.

Here is my practical advice. One hidden account is rarely the only one. If you suspect there is more, do not go back to court for the single statement that happened to fall into your hands. Reopen the matter, say plainly that you want discovery, and find out what else was never disclosed.

ASK STACY: I just passed the bar, and I have gotten offers from both a large full-service firm with a small family law group and a boutique shop that only does divorce work. Everyone tells me the name-brand firm looks better on paper, but I keep wondering if I would actually learn more, faster, somewhere smaller. How would you weigh that decision if you were starting over today?

MY THOUGHTS: I have done both. I worked at a large firm and then at a boutique family law firm. For years after that, I ran my own firm with partners and associates. This was a boutique firm built around one specialty. Then ten years ago I merged that firm into Blank Rome.

The size of the letterhead matters far less than the people whose names are on it. Ask who you would actually be working with day to day. Will they take the time to train you? Will they let you do real work? Is the culture sink-or-swim? Because I don't believe in that mentality. You should be trained, and a larger firm usually has more structure built for professional development. Larger firms also tend to pay better as you move up the ranks, but in my experience, the billable-hour requirements are often higher than at a boutique firm. With the money comes a longer ladder to climb and different expectations for how you spend your time.

Then ask what you want your practice to look like in fifteen years. Do you want to do family law forever? Do you see yourself in a boutique or somewhere large? One question tends to settle it. Do you enjoy selling and marketing yourself? If that doesn't appeal to you, go to the bigger firm.

ASK STACY: My husband and I got married eighteen months ago and are already talking divorce. Everyone keeps telling me short marriages are "easy" to end, but I do not actually know what that means for dividing what we have built or whether I would be entitled to any support. Does the short length of our marriage change how California handles any of this?

MY THOUGHTS: It can be easy. It can also be complicated. Everything turns on what the two of you acquired during your marriage. Start with a house, if there is one. Did you buy it together during the marriage, or was it a gift to one of you? If it came as a gift, did it come with equity, or only a share of the appreciation? Were investments made from earnings during the marriage? Eighteen months is a short window, but even a short window can hold a great deal. One spouse can earn twenty million dollars in eighteen months.

On support, the general guideline for a marriage of this length is one-half the length of the marriage. If you had a child during that time, it can affect the duration of spousal support, and child support enters the picture as well.

So your divorce will probably not carry the weight of a forty-year marriage. Whether it turns out simple or genuinely difficult depends on your facts and circumstances.

Please note: The content and views expressed here are my own and do not reflect or represent the positions, strategies, views, or opinions of Blank Rome LLP.

Next
Next

Show Me the Money: The Vital Role of Forensic Accountants in Complex Divorce Cases